Skip to content

Section 1.2: The Three Tricks for Calculating Quantities

Exam Alert: This is a SUPER POPULAR exam topic. Almost every exam has a 13-15 mark question asking you to "estimate quantities using centre line method" or "calculate brickwork using long wall-short wall method." Master this and you've got easy marks.

The Core Idea (The "Ah, This is Easy" Moment)

Look, here's the deal: You need to calculate how much brick/concrete/whatever you need for walls. But walls meet at corners, right? So if you measure each wall separately, you'll count the corners twice. These three methods are just different ways to avoid double-counting corners. That's literally it.

Think of it like this: You're ordering pizza for a party. If you count "4 people want pepperoni" and separately "3 people want pepperoni," you might order for 7 people when 2 people were counted twice. Same logic here.

Method 1: Long Wall - Short Wall Method

The Concept: Some walls run the full length (long walls), others fit between them (short walls). Decide which is which, measure accordingly.

How It Works:

Step 1: Draw the building plan. Look at it. Pick which walls run "through" - those are your long walls (walls that go the full outside dimension).

Step 2: The walls that fit "between" the long walls? Those are short walls (they're shorter because they stop where long walls are).

Step 3:

  • Long wall length = Centre line length (the middle line of the wall) + half the wall thickness on EACH end

  • Why? Because it extends into the corner on both sides

  • Short wall length = Centre line length - half the wall thickness on EACH end

  • Why? Because the long walls already claimed that corner space

Step 4: Multiply length × breadth (wall thickness) × height = Volume (in cubic meters, or m³ - just the 3D space it occupies)

The Memory Trick:

"LONG walls are LONGER (add thickness), SHORT walls are SHORTER (subtract thickness)"

Visualize: You're building a picture frame. The top and bottom pieces (long) overlap the side pieces (short) at corners. The top piece needs extra length to cover the corner wood, the side pieces need less because they don't go all the way.

When to Use This:

  • When walls have different thicknesses (like main walls are 30cm thick, partition walls are 20cm thick)
  • When foundation levels are different for different walls
  • It's more detailed but takes longer

Check Example 1.5 in estimation_20251127.pdf (page 1.13-1.15) - shows the complete calculation table format

source: "https://prepp.in/question/which-one-of-the-following-is-correct-statement-fo-645d2db8e8610180957e5450"

Understanding the Long Wall and Short Wall Method

The long wall and short wall method is a common technique used in estimating the quantities of materials for buildings, especially for masonry structures. In this method, the walls along the length of the building are considered 'long walls', and the walls along the width of the building are considered 'short walls'. The key to this method is calculating the lengths of these walls accurately at different stages of construction, such as earthwork, foundation, and superstructure.

Calculating Wall Lengths in Different Stages

In the long wall and short wall method, calculations are often based on the centre-to-centre lengths of the walls. The centre-to-centre length is the distance between the centre lines of the wall intersections.

  • For the long wall, the length is calculated by adding the width of the relevant section (like the trench width for earthwork or the wall width for superstructure) to the centre-to-centre length. This can be visualized as the centre-to-centre length plus half the width on one side and half the width on the other side, totaling the full width.
  • For the short wall, the length is calculated by subtracting the width of the relevant section from the centre-to-centre length. This is because the length added to the long wall at the corners is subtracted from the short wall to avoid double-counting.

Method 2: Centre Line Method

The Concept: Forget long/short. Just trace one continuous line through the CENTER of all walls, measure that total length, multiply by wall thickness and height. Done.

How It Works:

Step 1: Imagine you're a tiny ant walking through the exact middle of all the walls. Your walking path length = centre line length

Step 2: At junctions (where walls meet), be careful: - If walls join in a "T" shape, reduce the centre line by half the wall thickness at that junction - If it's a cross "+", reduce by half thickness for each arm that joins - Why? To avoid counting that junction space multiple times

Step 3: Total centre line × wall thickness × height = Volume

That's it. One calculation. Boom.

The Memory Trick:

"ONE LINE TO RULE THEM ALL" (yes, Lord of the Rings)

Visualize: You're drawing with a marker through the middle of a maze. You want the total ink used (length of your line) × marker thickness × how tall you drew it = total ink volume.

When to Use This:

  • When all walls have the same thickness throughout
  • When you want quick calculations
  • Most popular in exams because it's elegant and fast
  • Less chance of errors

Check Example 1.5 in estimation_20251127.pdf (page 1.13-1.15) - they show both methods side by side so you can compare

Method 3: Partly Centre Line and Short Wall Method

The Concept: Use centre line method for outer (external) walls because they're uniform, use long wall-short wall method for inner (internal) walls because they vary.

How It Works:

Step 1: Calculate outer boundary walls using the centre line method (they're usually all the same thickness - 30cm or whatever)

Step 2: Calculate inner partition walls (the walls dividing rooms inside) using long wall-short wall method because: - Some might be 20cm thick - Some might be 10cm thick (half-brick partition walls - walls made with bricks laid on their side) - They might have different foundation depths

Step 3: Add both calculations together

The Memory Trick:

"OUTSIDE = Simple (one line), INSIDE = Complicated (long-short)"

Visualize: The building is like a box with compartments. The box itself (outside) is uniform - one measurement works. The compartments inside are all different sizes - need individual attention.

When to Use This:

  • Most practical method in real construction
  • When external walls are uniform but internal walls vary
  • Very common in exam problems that show buildings with verandahs (covered entrance areas), partition walls, bathrooms with different wall thicknesses

Check Example 1.7 in estimation_20251127.pdf (page 1.20-1.23) - perfect example with verandah and different wall types

The Exam Strategy (How to Score Easy Marks):

What Examiners Want to See:

  1. Correct method selection - They'll give you a plan. You pick the right method and MENTION why you picked it:
  2. "Using centre line method as all walls are of uniform 30cm thickness"

  3. "Using long wall-short wall method as walls have different thicknesses"

  4. Neat calculation table format (see the PDF examples): 

    S.No | Particulars | Nos | L | B | H | Quantity | Remarks

  5. Proper units: Always m³ (cubic meters) for volumes, m² (square meters) for areas, m (meters) for lengths

  6. Show your work: Write "L = 5.3 + 0.3" not just "L = 5.6"

  7. Deductions: If there are doors/windows/openings, always deduct them and show it separately

Common Mistakes (Avoid These):

❌ Mixing up when to add/subtract wall thickness
✅ Remember: Long walls ADD, short walls SUBTRACT

❌ Forgetting to convert cm to meters (30cm = 0.3m)
✅ Always work in meters for final calculations

❌ Not showing where dimensions came from
✅ Write remarks: "L = 10.6 + 0.4" (centre dimension + half thickness)

❌ Calculating in only 2D (forgetting height)
✅ Volume always needs 3 dimensions: Length × Breadth × Height

The One Thing to Remember:

All three methods are just different ways to avoid counting corners twice.

  • Method 1 (Long-Short): Manually decide which wall "owns" each corner
  • Method 2 (Centre Line): One line through middle = no corner conflicts
  • Method 3 (Hybrid): Centre line for simple parts, long-short for complex parts

That's it. Everything else is just arithmetic. The concept is trivial - don't double-count corners. The execution requires careful attention to which method suits the situation.

Exam Success Formula: Pick the right method → Set up the table → Calculate carefully → Deduct openings → Show units → Easy 13 marks! 🎯

Practice Problems in PDFs: - Example 1.5 (page 1.13): Single room - both methods shown - Example 1.6 (page 1.15): Two rooms - more complex
- Example 1.7 (page 1.20): With verandah - hybrid method - Example 1.8 (page 1.26): Residential building - full calculation


Comments